How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Mom
January 8th, 2009An assessment of both Vivians in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.
No matter what season, The Fresh Prince is always good to watch. Ever since NickGAS turned into The N and Legends of the Hidden Temple couldn’t be played all day, The Fresh Prince is usually what my television lands on, considering that it is always on at least one station at any given time. Given the constancy in viewing the show for the bulk of my life, I have come to the conclusion that I like the old Vivian more than the new one. More importantly, I believe I enjoyed the show more in the old Vivian years than in the new Vivian ones. The latter point isn’t wholly the case because of the Vivian switch, given that I like both Vivians and the show in its entirety (with the exception of the episodes dealing with Ashley being a pop star). I enjoy the old Vivian episodes more because I think as a whole they’re funnier. However, In assessing the show and the Vivian split, it has made me think about what the change in Vivians did for the show.
A little history: Janet-Hubert Whitten was Vivian 1, and was so from 1990 to 1993. Because of creative differences, she left the show right when the character Nicky was born, and then Daphne Reed took over as Vivian 2 until the end of the series. With the change in actresses came the shift in characteristics that “Vivian” possesses. Vivian 1 is a professor of black history and literature, while Vivian 2 seems to stay at home. This can possibly be explained by filling in the storyline with Vivian wanting to stay home with Nicky after being born and just never teaching again. However, since there is no explanation (that I’m aware of), I take it that the switch in actresses and careers for the character is because the writers wanted to change the mother’s dynamic within the show.
Given my assumption is correct, was the shift for the best?
I think this is how it breaks down: Vivian 1 was certainly more academically minded. She consistently made sure that Will had his head in the right place when thinking on issues that he was passionate about, but seeming mislead in formulating his beliefs on (ex. her critique on what Will finds important about the Civil Rights Movement and Malcom X in general). Overall, Vivian 1 has more fruitful discourse with her children and additional characters concerning school and life decisions than Vivian 2 has. Considering when Will is dating one of Vivian’s students, Kayla, she has a discussion with both of them respectively concerning what their relationship is doing to Kayla’s academic career. In contrast, Vivian 2 does not have arguments with the characters. Rather, she either chimes in after the fact or simply makes little quips while Phil is arguing or after he finishes. An example of this is when Vivian 2 does not express her opinion of Will’s father when he comes back until Phil is about to tell Lou that he has made a huge mistake in coming back for Will then leaving without him. Whereas Phil and Vivian initially governed the family on more equal footing, it is clear that the Banks household is merely a patriarchy when Vivian 2 is present.
Though Vivian 2 is less authoritative and seemingly less analytically minded, she puts more focus on the family than Vivian 1 does. Considering the same episode involving Will’s father, though she does not assert her opinion of Lou until the end, she states that it is important for a boy to have his father in his life, tacitly implying that it is acceptable that Lou is back. Furthermore, though discussion of her and Phil’s relationship tends to veer away from anything regarding protests and civil rights, more emphasis is placed on their love for one another and sustaining it (ex. the soul train episode where Phil confesses his love to her again). Her advice is also beneficial to an aging Will as he prepares to get married to Lisa, when she tells him how to act as a husband.
Though I love Vivian 1 and every moment she took her earrings off in a fit of rage while Phil had to hold her back from fighting whomever was angering her, I’ve grown to appreciate Vivian 2’s contribution to the show. The project now is to keep a count of how many episodes have Vivian 2 telling Phil that he can sleep on the couch.
-ryan






